Consult with Dr. B.

[jentop]

I agree with your decision to go forward. I recently (Jan 27th)had 2 level cervical ADR with Dr. Bertagnoli for the same reasons(plus more-ie:high pain levels at times, cord impingement/compression depending on who was reading the films, etc)and am very glad I did. My recovery has for the most part been remarkable. I still experience some pain, though nothing like before. Also, I am menopausal(nearing age 50)but probably due to my active lifestyle(the same one that has screwed up my spine)my bone density is still excellent.
I also have the same levels of DDD in my lumbar spine, though not yet a surgical candidate. I also have been told that I have a transitional vertebrae. So, with all things being equal, I would want to get ahead of the game too and try to prevent the domino effect if possible. I wish you the best of luck. I can reiterate that Dr. FM is wonderful too. When I finally got to meet her in person, I was very impressed. She had been out with the flu when I arrived, but I saw her for my 1 week postop appt and she was great!

[Kathy]

Jentop's post reminded me of the domino effect....
My pre-surgery MRI and the one before it were done 10 months apart, with no new trauma during that time. During that time the DDD progression was signigicant and L5/S1 & L3/L4 now both have a 1mm herniation (this was not there before) You are very lucky to have the knowledge you have and be able to get surgery done in a timely manner. My previous dr never even told me that I had ddd, or that I was a surgical canidate. I was simply told there was nothing else that they could do for me. I spent 3 years trying to figure out what was wrong with me.

[Cindylou]

Cathy,

Boy, Justin really nailed it. And everyone else for that matter. Go for it, and reclaim your life back! We're here for you on the other side.

My best,

Cindylou

[treefrog]

Well, I am still waiting for a surgery date. Perhaps Dr. Fenk-Mayer decided to take some vacation time too.

Yesterday I talked to the ortho surgeon that I consulted with back in December. He said he does not like to take on other surgeon's "problems". So, if I were to need follow-up care after surgery, he wouldn't do it. Well, that's disappointing. I hope my PM doctor will continue to see me, and will prescribe medications for whatever I might need to take with me.

Of course he tried to talk me out of going to Germany. He said he thought I could get two-level ADR, and pay out of pocket here in the US for less than $40,000. HA! He also said there were no results to prove that 2-level disc replacement (ADR) is any better than 2-level fusion. He said fusion is not perfect, but neither is ADR, and he thinks that if you are going to have problems after surgery, it wouldn't matter if you have fusion or ADR. Basically saying that some people are just going to have problems no matter what surgery they have.

My interpretation of the above opinions - first he is only basing his opinions on results from US investigations (clinical trials and surgeries). He even told me at our consult that he there isn't much reliable data coming from Europe, because they don't have the same standards that we do. And if I look at just US results, I don't think it looks very good either, which is why I want to go to Germany.

Then he said that if it were him, he would choose 2-level fusion over 2-level ADR, and hybrid over 2-level fusion.

I didn't get around to saying one of the other reasons for going to Germany was experience. He mentioned that he has done about a dozen hybrid surgeries. That is laughable. Compared to the thousands of ADR surgeries Dr. Bertagnoli has done. But, at least I didn't have to get into it with him.

[Justin]

Hey Cathy, see the bolded text below:

Originally Posted by treefrog

Well, I am still waiting for a surgery date. Perhaps Dr. Fenk-Mayer decided to take some vacation time too.

I'm thinking that this is what it is. They are usually SWAMPED with patients from all over the world. Vacation is extremely rare for Drs. Bertagnoli an Fenk-Mayer.

Yesterday I talked to the ortho surgeon that I consulted with back in December. He said he does not like to take on other surgeon's "problems". So, if I were to need follow-up care after surgery, he wouldn't do it. Well, that's disappointing. I hope my PM doctor will continue to see me, and will prescribe medications for whatever I might need to take with me.

Find another surgeon to follow you. Better yet, Dr. Bertagnoli will probably suggest one that he has trained or knows well in your area. Keep your head up. Your PM should be sympathetic, but definitely find a surgeon for follow-up (X-rays, etc.).

Of course he tried to talk me out of going to Germany. He said he thought I could get two-level ADR, and pay out of pocket here in the US for less than $40,000. HA! He also said there were no results to prove that 2-level disc replacement (ADR) is any better than 2-level fusion. He said fusion is not perfect, but neither is ADR, and he thinks that if you are going to have problems after surgery, it wouldn't matter if you have fusion or ADR. Basically saying that some people are just going to have problems no matter what surgery they have.

40k...hehe... 2-level fusions are devastating operations on adjacent levels in a significant amount of cases with patients that are young and lead relatively active lifestyles. True... both fusion and ADR have problems. However if patient selection, appropriate pre-op diagnostic bases are covered and an experienced surgeon are in the mix, one's outcome is favorable with ADR. ADR is not a fix-all operation, and I think most of us know this on this forum. In many cases it's the "better" option among the few options we have as spine patients facing surgical intervention.

My interpretation of the above opinions - first he is only basing his opinions on results from US investigations (clinical trials and surgeries). He even told me at our consult that he there isn't much reliable data coming from Europe, because they don't have the same standards that we do. And if I look at just US results, I don't think it looks very good either, which is why I want to go to Germany.

True, the German studies vary greatly. However, this doesn't mean that we should completely throw out that data. US results are better in the short-term in regard to VAS/oswestry, return to work, range of motion, etc. Long-term results are still up in the air.

Then he said that if it were him, he would choose 2-level fusion over 2-level ADR, and hybrid over 2-level fusion.

In my opinion, this is nonsense. I spoke with a surgeon this weekend about my situation and he agreed that as an active, 23-year-old at the time of my surgery that he would have done the same (picked the 2-level ADR as opposed to fusion). He agreed that I would have significantly greater issues and have had many more surgeries by now. However, I do know that my 3rd surgery coming up will not be the last in my life.

Cathy, he is just talking about what he knows. ADR is still in its infancy and many surgeons dismiss it right off the bat.

I didn't get around to saying one of the other reasons for going to Germany was experience. He mentioned that he has done about a dozen hybrid surgeries. That is laughable. Compared to the thousands of ADR surgeries Dr. Bertagnoli has done. But, at least I didn't have to get into it with him.

IMHO, experience is the MOST IMPORTANT factor in the surgical equation. For example, the one of the great things about Dr. Bertagnoli is that he will do a discogram on an uncertain level "himself" during an operation when he believes another disc is suspect. Incredible. Dr. Bertagnoli's experience speaks volumes, as he has seen extremely difficulty cases, emergent cases that are medevaced to him, etc...plus he has used practically every device on the market. He truly knows what device/intervention is the best in a patient's situation...why?...one word... EXPERIENCE.

Good luck and keep me posted... I have an interesting story for you.

[treefrog]

Thanks Justin. Experience of the surgeon is the most important aspect on surgical outcome, in my opinion as well. And even if Dr. Bertagnoli thought that a hybrid surgery would be better for me than 2 ADR, I would still want him to do the surgery.

I also have a physical this Friday, and will be asking them to do the blood work (which reminds me, I have to write to Pro Spine and ask how important it is to have this done two weeks before surgery), required for surgery. I think I will ask them, if I don't have an alternative if they will order follow-up x-rays for me. Then I can send them to Dr. Bertagnoli for review.

[steve55]

Yes! Dr b did a interop discogram on my suspect c4/5 and it turns out it was REALLY bad! He saved me a ton of money and suffering as I likely would have eventually started having pain from that level also. Dr b's consistent successful results speak for themselves.